·

·

12

min read

AI documentation tools across European languages

Why AI documentation tools perform differently across European languages in primary care. Language-specific validation, dialect variation, and clinical coding challenges explained

Multilingual AI documentation interface supporting European healthcare systems

Artificial intelligence (AI) documentation tools perform unevenly across European languages because they were trained predominantly on English data. In multilingual primary care, that gap creates a direct patient safety risk.

How errors compound across the ASR and NLP pipeline

Most AI documentation tools used in primary care combine two components. The first is automatic speech recognition (ASR), which converts spoken words into text. The second is a large language model (LLM) or natural language processing (NLP) layer, which turns that transcribed text into structured clinical documentation. Errors build up across both stages. If the ASR layer mishears a clinical term pronounced with a regional accent, the NLP layer receives corrupted input and may then generate a note that sounds plausible but is clinically wrong. Clinicians evaluating these tools should therefore ask not just "does it support this language?" but "where in the pipeline does it fail, and how?"

Why some European languages are better supported than others

The fundamental reason for performance differences is an imbalance in training data. When a model has been trained on billions of English clinical documents but only millions, or hundreds of thousands, of equivalent texts in Dutch, Romanian, or Greek, its performance in those languages will be structurally weaker. Research published in Scientific Reports in 2025 examined the challenges foundational large language models face in specialist tasks such as medical summarisation. The difficulties include morphological richness, where words change form extensively depending on grammar; syntactic variation; and diglossia, where a language has two distinct forms used in different contexts. The impact falls hardest on underrepresented languages.

English is best supported by a substantial margin. Spanish, French, and German have reasonable coverage, though with gaps in clinical vocabulary. Dutch, Portuguese, and Italian sit somewhere in the middle. Languages that are likely to be underrepresented, including Polish, Romanian, Greek, Czech, Hungarian, Finnish, Catalan, Welsh, and Maltese, should be independently verified by clinicians before deployment.

Language family structure creates predictable failure modes

Germanic, Romance, and Slavic languages each create distinct error patterns that clinicians can anticipate.

German and Dutch make heavy use of compound nouns. A term such as Herzinsuffizienz (heart failure) or Bluthochdruck (hypertension) needs to be recognised as a single clinical entity. AI tools that haven't been trained on enough German-language clinical text frequently split or misrecognise these compounds, producing notes that omit or distort the diagnosis.

Romance languages assign grammatical gender to medical terminology, and clinical meaning can shift when gender agreement goes wrong. Regional variation in clinical vocabulary is also significant: the same condition may be described with different preferred terms in France versus Belgium, or in Spain versus Latin America. Research on bilingual Spanish and Catalan primary care notes found that recognising diagnoses and linking them to International Classification of Diseases, Tenth Revision (ICD-10) codes in non-standard bilingual notes is a distinct and demanding problem, one that requires language-specific fine-tuning of the model.

Polish and Czech present the steepest challenge of the three families. Their extensive inflectional systems change word endings based on grammatical case, gender, and number, meaning a clinical term for a condition may appear in six or more different forms within a single consultation. Multilingual trustworthiness evaluations of large language models in healthcare identify the lack of reliable evaluation in multilingual settings as a critical barrier to real-world adoption. The benchmark cited covers 15 languages while excluding Polish, Czech, and Slovak entirely, which indicates how thin the evidence base currently is for those languages.

Dialects, accented speech, and code-switching: the layers most tools ignore

Even within a single officially supported language, dialect variation and accented speech can substantially reduce ASR accuracy. A tool validated for standard Dutch may still underperform in a Flemish general practice (GP) in Ghent. Swiss German is distinct enough from standard German that many ASR systems trained on Hochdeutsch (standard High German) can't reliably transcribe it. Catalan, spoken by millions across Spain and France, is frequently treated as an edge case by vendors whose primary market is Castilian Spanish.

A narrative review from Dublin City University's ADAPT Centre identifies this as one of the central unresolved challenges in AI language technology for healthcare. Producing fluent output in a standard language variety does not guarantee acceptable performance across the full range of dialects. The review also notes that efficiency gains from AI language tools can hide errors, reduce traceability, and shift responsibility across clinicians and health systems, risks that are amplified when dialect variation hasn't been accounted for during validation.

Accented speech from non-native speakers presents a related but distinct challenge. A Romanian-born GP practising in Ireland and documenting in English with a Romanian accent may find that ASR accuracy is meaningfully lower than for a native English speaker using the same tool. This has direct implications for practices with internationally trained clinicians, who make up a significant proportion of primary care workforces across the European Union (EU) and United Kingdom (UK).

Code-switching, moving between two or more languages within a single conversation, is routine in multilingual clinical settings, yet it remains one of the most poorly handled scenarios in AI documentation tools. A clinician in Luxembourg may document in French while using Latin anatomical terms, English drug names, and the occasional German phrase. For most current tools, code-switching between a well-resourced and an under-resourced language produces one of two failure modes: the tool defaults entirely to the dominant language and drops content spoken in the minority language, or it attempts to transcribe both but introduces systematic errors at the points where the language switches. Both outcomes carry patient safety implications when missed or distorted information reaches the clinical record.

Clinical terminology across languages is not a translation problem

A common assumption is that multilingual clinical documentation is primarily a translation challenge, that an AI tool simply needs to map spoken terms in one language to their English equivalents before applying standard clinical coding. Medical vocabulary is not uniformly standardised across European languages. Systematised Nomenclature of Medicine Clinical Terms (SNOMED CT) has official translations in several European languages, but coverage is uneven. Clinicians frequently use informal, abbreviated, or locally preferred terms that don't map directly to any standardised code. A tool trained on English clinical data may correctly recognise "heart failure" and map it to the appropriate SNOMED CT code, then fail to do the same when the term is spoken in Polish, Greek, or Finnish, even if the tool nominally "supports" those languages.

Research on ICD-10 coding in bilingual Spanish and Catalan primary care notes found that non-standard note formats and bilingual mixing create specific challenges that can't be resolved by applying models trained on standard monolingual data. Training on combined bilingual data, rather than language-specific data alone, consistently produced the best generalisation, a finding with direct implications for any practice evaluating AI documentation tools in a non-English European language.

What to ask vendors before deploying in a multilingual practice

Clinicians and practice managers should go beyond vendor marketing claims and ask specific, verifiable questions. The 2025 commentary on AI scribes in healthcare notes that most existing evaluations come from small-scale, short-term pilot studies with participants who were already favourably disposed towards technology, a limitation that applies with particular force to non-English language evaluations, where the evidence base is thinner still.

Four areas warrant specific scrutiny. First, language-specific validation data: in which languages was the tool validated, on what dataset, and what was the word error rate for ASR in the target language compared to English on the same tool? Second, dialect and accent coverage: has the tool been tested on the specific regional variety used in your practice, such as Flemish Dutch or Swiss German, and what is the documented performance difference from the standard variety? Third, code-switching capability: how does the tool behave when medical terms are spoken in Latin or English within a non-English consultation, and does the vendor back this up with accuracy data rather than a qualitative description? Fourth, ICD/SNOMED coding accuracy: a tool may achieve acceptable transcription accuracy while still failing to generate correct codes in the target language, so ask vendors for coding accuracy data specific to your language and clinical context.

Red flags suggesting inadequate multilingual validation include accuracy figures presented as a single number across all supported languages without a language-specific breakdown, validation carried out on clean recordings rather than real-world clinical speech, and dialect or code-switching performance described qualitatively rather than backed by data. The EuropeMedQA study protocol (currently a preprint) proposes a multilingual medical examination dataset drawn from official regulatory exams in Italy, France, Spain, and Portugal, an early structured framework for comparing large language model performance across those four clinical languages. Performance on standardised examination questions involves different linguistic registers and different types of error than real-world clinical speech, so the framework represents a starting point for structured comparison rather than a substitute for clinical validation in practice settings.

GDPR and regulatory considerations for multilingual AI tools in the EU

Audio recordings of clinical consultations in any language constitute sensitive health data under Article 9 of the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) and carry the full range of data protection obligations. Practices should verify where audio data is processed and stored. Some tools route audio to cloud infrastructure outside the EU for transcription, which requires appropriate transfer safeguards under Chapter V of the GDPR, not outright prohibited, but the safeguards must be in place. Tools that process non-English audio through different infrastructure than English audio may apply inconsistent data residency arrangements, and that inconsistency is worth probing directly with vendors rather than assuming it has been resolved.

Medical Device Regulation (MDR) status is also relevant. AI documentation tools that generate clinical outputs may qualify as medical devices, and where they do, this affects which languages and clinical contexts must be formally validated. A BMJ policy paper on AI in healthcare identifies the gap between rapidly accelerating AI deployment and the regulatory frameworks designed to govern it as a significant concern across multilingual settings.

What needs to change

The multilingual performance gap isn't intractable, but both research and commercial vendors are currently underserving it. Three changes are needed. Health systems, research funders, and AI vendors must invest in building clinically validated datasets in Polish, Romanian, Greek, Dutch, and other underrepresented languages. The ADAPT Centre's 2026 review argues this requires not only better models but accountable design of the wider sociotechnical systems involved, and stronger collaboration across natural language processing, clinical practice, and policy. Developers also need to build dialect awareness into models from the start: standard language varieties aren't sufficient as the basis for clinical AI validation, and models need to be tested and fine-tuned on the regional varieties that clinicians actually use. Most importantly, regulators should make clinical validation a requirement. Without regulatory pressure, vendors have limited commercial incentive to invest in validation for smaller language markets, and the gap will persist regardless of how much the underlying technology improves.

Language support listed on a vendor's website reflects a commercial claim, not a validated clinical standard. Applying the questions and benchmarks above rigorously before deployment is the most reliable protection against the compounding errors that multilingual AI documentation tools can introduce into clinical records.

Frequently asked questions

▶ Why do AI documentation tools perform differently across European languages?

Training data volume is the deciding factor. A model exposed to billions of English clinical documents but only hundreds of thousands in Romanian will carry that imbalance into every consultation. The gap compounds because errors in the transcription layer feed directly into the note-generation layer, so a single mishearing can corrupt the final clinical record.

▶ Which European languages are best and least supported by clinical AI documentation tools?

English leads by a wide margin, followed by Spanish, French, and German with moderate clinical vocabulary gaps. Dutch, Portuguese, and Italian sit in the middle tier. Polish, Romanian, Greek, Czech, Hungarian, Finnish, Catalan, Welsh, and Maltese are consistently underrepresented. For any of these, treat vendor claims as a starting point and run your own accuracy checks before deployment.

▶ What specific documentation errors should clinicians expect with Germanic and Slavic languages?

German and Dutch compound nouns are split or dropped when a model lacks sufficient clinical training data in those languages. Polish and Czech inflectional systems produce six or more surface forms for a single clinical term, so a model that hasn't seen enough variation will treat the same diagnosis as multiple unrelated words and miss it in coding.

▶ Does dialect and accented speech affect AI documentation accuracy?

Yes. Validation on a standard language variety gives no guarantee of performance in regional speech. The practical implication for practice managers is to ask vendors for accuracy figures recorded in the specific dialect your clinicians use, not figures averaged across a language. A single number covering all varieties of Dutch, for example, can mask a large gap between standard and Flemish performance.

▶ How do AI documentation tools handle code-switching, where clinicians mix languages mid-consultation?

Current tools default to one of two failure modes: dropping content spoken in the minority language entirely, or transcribing both languages but introducing errors at every switch point. Practices where code-switching is routine should ask vendors for accuracy data recorded on mixed-language speech, since qualitative descriptions of multilingual capability are not a substitute for measured performance.

▶ Is multilingual clinical documentation just a translation problem?

The coding layer makes it harder than translation. Even where transcription is accurate, a tool must map locally preferred or informal terms to the correct SNOMED CT or ICD-10 code in the target language. Research on bilingual Spanish and Catalan notes found that training on combined bilingual data, rather than separate monolingual datasets, produced the best coding generalisation, a finding vendors rarely address in their documentation.

▶ What questions should clinicians ask vendors when evaluating an AI documentation tool for a multilingual practice?

Ask for word error rate in your specific language and dialect, clinical terminology recognition rates for your most common diagnoses, and coding accuracy in your language compared to English on the same tool. If a vendor describes dialect or code-switching performance in qualitative terms rather than with figures, treat that as a gap in their validation, not a feature description.

▶ What are the GDPR implications of using AI documentation tools that process non-English audio?

Check whether non-English audio is routed through different infrastructure than English audio. Some vendors apply inconsistent data residency arrangements by language, which means the transfer safeguards required under Chapter V of the GDPR may not be in place for your consultations even if they are in place for English ones. Ask vendors to confirm this in writing rather than assuming it is covered by a general compliance statement.

▶ What accuracy benchmarks indicate an AI documentation tool is suitable for clinical use in a non-English language?

Minimum thresholds to request from vendors: ASR word error rate below 10 to 15 per cent for the specific language and dialect in use, clinical terminology recognition above 80 per cent for common diagnostic terms, and ICD or SNOMED coding accuracy comparable to the same tool's English performance. A single accuracy figure covering all supported languages, or validation on clean studio recordings, does not meet these thresholds.

▶ What changes are needed before AI documentation tools can be considered reliably safe across multilingual European primary care?

Three things: clinically validated datasets in underrepresented languages, dialect-aware model development that covers regional varieties rather than only standard forms, and regulatory requirements that make clinical validation mandatory before deployment. The ADAPT Centre's 2026 review argues this also requires stronger collaboration across natural language processing research, clinical practice, and policy, not only better underlying models.

Get started with Tandem today

Join thousands of clinicians enjoying stress-free documentation.

Get started with Tandem today

Join thousands of clinicians enjoying stress-free documentation.

Get started with Tandem today

Join thousands of clinicians enjoying stress-free documentation.